In the complex world of marketing and consumer decision-making, the role of personal beliefs and psychological tendencies can be powerful. Dogmatism, a personality trait defined by rigid adherence to one’s own beliefs and resistance to new ideas, plays a critical role in how individuals approach brands, products, and advertising. In consumer behaviour, dogmatism influences the willingness of a person to try new products, switch brands, or accept different opinions about quality and value. Understanding how dogmatism affects purchasing decisions helps marketers craft more effective strategies that cater to different personality profiles in the marketplace.
Understanding Dogmatism in Consumer Behaviour
Dogmatism refers to the tendency of individuals to be closed-minded and resistant to change, especially when it comes to beliefs and ideas. In consumer behaviour, dogmatism manifests as a reluctance to consider new or unfamiliar brands, products, or services. Consumers with high dogmatism often rely on traditional or well-established products and avoid innovation or change.
This trait can significantly shape the market, as it leads to loyalty toward specific brands and a reduced responsiveness to marketing campaigns that emphasize novelty, risk-taking, or experimentation. On the other hand, low-dogmatism consumers are more open to new experiences and are more easily influenced by persuasive advertising or peer recommendations.
Key Characteristics of Dogmatic Consumers
- Prefer familiar brands over new ones
- Less influenced by new trends or marketing appeals
- Highly loyal to products they already trust
- Reluctant to change buying habits
- Seek validation in structured, clear messaging
Examples of Dogmatism in Consumer Behaviour
Brand Loyalty in Automotive Choices
One of the clearest examples of dogmatism in consumer behaviour is brand loyalty in the automotive industry. Some consumers consistently purchase vehicles from a single manufacturer, such as Ford, Toyota, or BMW, and remain resistant to exploring alternatives, even when competitors may offer better features or value. This loyalty is not just based on satisfaction it’s rooted in a belief that their preferred brand represents superior quality or reliability. Such consumers may ignore new brands or models because they do not fit their established views of what makes a ‘good car.’
Resistance to Changing Mobile Phone Brands
In the tech industry, dogmatism is often observed in users who are loyal to Apple or Android smartphones. An individual who has used an iPhone for years may resist switching to an Android device regardless of new features, pricing, or peer reviews. This behaviour stems from a psychological commitment to the brand and the belief that alternatives cannot match their trusted product. This resistance is not necessarily rational but is driven by a deep-seated adherence to familiar systems.
Preference for Traditional Foods and Brands
In the food and beverage industry, dogmatism is common among consumers who stick to heritage brands or traditional products. For instance, someone who has always bought Coca-Cola may be unwilling to try Pepsi or any other soda. Even if there is a new drink with healthier ingredients or unique flavors, a dogmatic consumer may reject it purely because it doesn’t align with their long-standing preference. The same applies to food brands, such as sticking with the same brand of pasta or cereal for decades.
Reluctance to Try New Beauty or Skincare Products
Consumers with high dogmatism are often reluctant to try new cosmetics or skincare brands. They may be highly loyal to one brand of moisturizer or foundation and avoid exploring newer, possibly more effective alternatives. This behaviour is typically rooted in a comfort with what is familiar, a fear of adverse reactions, and a perception that switching brands would involve unnecessary risk. These consumers require strong evidence and trust-building before they will consider altering their skincare routine.
Attachment to Traditional Media Channels
Another example is media consumption. A consumer who is dogmatic may only trust information from a specific news outlet or printed newspaper. They may refuse to engage with digital platforms or new media formats like podcasts, YouTube channels, or independent journalism. Their loyalty to traditional sources is based on a belief in their credibility, which aligns with their rigid thinking patterns. This kind of dogmatism can also influence purchasing behaviour, especially when marketing messages are delivered through unfamiliar channels.
Impact of Dogmatism on Marketing Strategies
Understanding the presence of dogmatism among consumers is crucial for marketers. Targeting high-dogmatism consumers requires a different approach than targeting those who are more open-minded. For dogmatic audiences, marketing messages should reinforce trust, familiarity, and consistency. Brands should focus on reinforcing existing brand values and leveraging reputation rather than highlighting innovation or change.
Effective Strategies for Dogmatic Consumers
- Emphasize brand heritage and tradition
- Use consistent messaging and visuals
- Highlight customer testimonials and social proof
- Avoid pushing radical product changes too quickly
- Focus on long-term reliability rather than novelty
Challenges for New Brands
New or unfamiliar brands often struggle to attract dogmatic consumers. Since these individuals are less willing to take risks, it can be difficult for startups or innovative products to break into markets dominated by legacy brands. These brands must invest more in credibility-building, such as third-party certifications, endorsements, and word-of-mouth promotion from trusted sources. Sometimes, entering the market through niche channels or limited releases can help build gradual trust among skeptical buyers.
Dogmatism in Online Shopping Behaviour
The rise of online shopping has also highlighted differences in dogmatic versus open-minded consumer behaviour. Dogmatic consumers are more likely to purchase from well-known e-commerce platforms such as Amazon or Walmart.com rather than exploring smaller retailers or niche marketplaces. They may avoid shopping on unfamiliar websites even if they offer better prices or more unique products. Security concerns, distrust of unfamiliar interfaces, and lack of physical interaction contribute to their hesitation.
Behavioural Patterns in E-Commerce
- Stick to well-known online retailers
- Rely heavily on brand reputation and reviews
- Prefer buying products they’ve used before
- Less responsive to experimental or trendy product launches
How Dogmatism Affects Product Reviews and Word-of-Mouth
Dogmatic consumers often become strong brand advocates but only for the brands they support. They are more likely to write positive reviews for products they already trust and may criticize new brands or competitors without fully exploring them. Their opinions can heavily influence others, especially in close social groups, creating ripple effects in purchasing behaviour. In contrast, low-dogmatism consumers are more willing to try something new and offer a more balanced view in their reviews.
Dogmatism in consumer behaviour is a powerful psychological factor that shapes how people make purchasing decisions. From sticking with familiar car brands to refusing to try new foods or cosmetics, dogmatic consumers are driven by a desire for consistency, trust, and risk avoidance. While this can be beneficial for brand loyalty, it poses challenges for new market entrants and marketers promoting innovation. By recognizing the signs of dogmatism and tailoring marketing efforts accordingly, brands can better engage their audience and build lasting relationships, even with the most change-resistant consumers.
#kebawah#